pierowmaniac wrote:
OK how about we go for the Nominations thread Idea and if its doesnt work ......IE we dont get enough people participating we then knock it on the head and do something different?

Does this sound fair?

Ill leave this suggestion open for a week so we can get anymore ideas first and also give us time to think about what songs we would want to nominate

agreed.

agreed but it is a long time from now. still got zeitgeist, machina 2, and judas o first.

First post updated with
Pisces Iscariot result.

current game
Machina II

To do
Zeitgeist
JudasO/Greatest hits
Best of the Rest (songs nominated by forum users)

Should give us 11 songs for the final game. Which is a good number for a Survivor game.

sounds good

How about a "Wild Card" survivor.

Once the 11 "album" are done, we could put all the finalist in one survivor to be the 12th member of the Final Survivor.

Some finalist could surely outlived some winners.

What do you think?

i'd like to do a 2nd place survivor as the wild card such as hello kitty kat for pisces and whatever else came in 2nd for other survivors. That'd be kinda cool...

JeePee73 wrote:
How about a "Wild Card" survivor.

Once the 11 "album" are done, we could put all the finalist in one survivor to be the 12th member of the Final Survivor.

Some finalist could surely outlived some winners.

What do you think?

Im not so sure seeing has the wildcard should theoreticaly lose to at least one other song on the ultimate survivor.

Having said that im not too bothered if thats what everyone feels like doing.

The Wild Card is probably not going to win the big thing.

But it could go as far as the top 5.

Ok, so out of what I read here, this is the plan:

-Judas 0 (curent)

-Zeitgeist (including all Zeitgeist Era official releases)

-Best of the rest (Users nominate favorite songs/b-sides that havn't been in a surviver game yet. After a period of nominations the most popular songs are selected.)

-2nd place surviver (all 2nd place songs from previous survivers are selected)

-Ultimate Surviver (Winner of each surviver is selected)



Sound good?

HeavyMetalMachine wrote:

Sound good?


Yep

The Nominations thread for "best of the rest" is now open

so are we just dropping the aeroplane box set? do those songs have to be put into the "best of the rest" category? I think we should do a separate one for the box set but take out the actual singles and songs that got their turn in some other game....

good question... i would like to see such songs as the last song having it's turn but the order of...

-Judas 0 (curent)

-Zeitgeist (including all Zeitgeist Era official releases)

-Best of the rest (Users nominate favorite songs/b-sides that havn't been in a surviver game yet. After a period of nominations the most popular songs are selected.)

-2nd place surviver (all 2nd place songs from previous survivers are selected)

-Ultimate Surviver (Winner of each surviver is selected)

... sounds very good. probably have to nominate them for the best of the rest.

yeah, TAFH should get its own survivor, c'mon what's the rush?

TAFH should get its own game after judas o.

Ok, I agree, lets organize this again:

-Judas 0 (curent)

-TAFH

-Zeitgeist (including all Zeitgeist Era official releases)

-Best of the rest (Users nominate favorite songs/b-sides that havn't been in a surviver game yet. After a period of nominations the most popular songs are selected.)

-2nd place surviver (all 2nd place songs from previous survivers are selected)

-Ultimate Surviver (Winner of each surviver is selected)

Now is everyone pleased? Looks good to me.

HeavyMetalMachine wrote:
Ok, I agree, lets organize this again:

-Judas 0 (curent)

-TAFH

-Zeitgeist (including all Zeitgeist Era official releases)

-Best of the rest (Users nominate favorite songs/b-sides that havn't been in a surviver game yet. After a period of nominations the most popular songs are selected.)

-2nd place surviver (all 2nd place songs from previous survivers are selected)

-Ultimate Surviver (Winner of each surviver is selected)

Now is everyone pleased? Looks good to me.

Thats better, but screw the previous 'Wild Card' idea cus thats crap.

LOL you guys keep changing your minds!

By the way is anyone recording the 2nd place songs which have been polled on the front page, because if not then we might as well ditch the wildcard idea here and now?

So how many songs are actually going to be on the TAFH survivor?
After you discount all the songs that have already had a go in previous games? (could work it out myself but I aint got the time at the moment)
Im still not sure its a good idea because theoreticaly why should only MCIS be the only album that also gets a B-Sides survivor. I think the songs from TAFH would make the "best of the rest" survivor a more interesting game.

Oh yeah by the way first post updated with Machina II survivor result!