...Said Sadly [4]
Ugly [7]
God [4]-
Mouths of Babes [15]
Rotten Apples [22]
Transformer [16]+

...Said Sadly [3]-
Ugly [7]
God [5]
Mouths of Babes [15]
Rotten Apples [23]+
Transformer [15]

OK...all songs that have already participated in preveious games have been pulled from the list. Trying to keep the list as short as possible, I left out Pastachio Medley because it's not really a song, but a conglomoration of song ideas. I Left out Tonight Reprise because it's just an extension of Tonight Tonight.

And as we disucssed in the other thread, we're starting everything at 3 points. We'll just see how it goes, but if the point totals get high and there's still a ton of songs left, we'll either nuke everything some points or re-set them all or whatever...we'll just figure that out when the time comes.

We have 23 songs here starting with 3 points each.

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [3]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medilla of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [3]
Transformer [3]
The Bells [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

and my vote for today:

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]+
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medilla of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [3]
Transformer [3]
The Bells [2]-
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]+
Transformer [3]
The Bells [1]-
My Blue Heaven [3]

"The Last Song" is one of my favorite Pumpkins songs, definitely in the top 20 at least. I might even go so far to say I like it better than "Set the Ray To Jerry" in terms of TAFH songs.

I am of the same mind, "The Bells"= one of the worst James Iha songs

..Said Sadly [4]+
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [3]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

The Bells is gone

...Said Sadly [3]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [2]-
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [4]+
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
The Bells [1]
My Blue Heaven [3]

JeePee and I went at the same time so here is the list:

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [3]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [1]-
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]+
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
Believe [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [3]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [3]
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

Am I missing something?

"Believe" is on Judas O isn't it?

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [1]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]+
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [3]
Blank [2]-
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

Dammit, I couldn't save "The Bells"...

How can it be one of the worst Iha songs?

It's better than "...Said Sadly" by far.

EDIT: Okay, I think it's just an honest mistake that "Believe" is in there, so I removed it from the list. Aren't I a good person?

Ah, so many of these songs are my favourite haha.
+ I liked the bells, not James' best (cough cough "GO" but Its a good song none the less.

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
A Night Like This [1]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]+
Blank [1]-
The Last Song [4]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [4]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [3]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
Blank [1]
The Last Song [5]+
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

A Night Like This is gone. Great original but man, Iha cannot hit them lower register notes.

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [3]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]+
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]-
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [4]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
Blank [1]
The Last Song [5]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

i'm still bummed about here's to the atom bomb losing judas 0

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]-
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]+
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]-
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]+
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
Blank [1]
The Last Song [5]
Transformer [3]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [3]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [5]
Transformer [4]+
My Blue Heaven [3]

Blank is gone.

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [4]
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [4]
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [2]-
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [6]+
Transformer [4]
My Blue Heaven [3]

...Said Sadly [4]
You're All I've Got Tonight [3]
Clones (We're All) [2]
Destination Unknown [3]
Dreaming [3]
Ugly [5]
The Boy [3]-
Cherry [3]
God [3]
Mouths of Babes [5]+
Tribute to Johnny [2]
Pennies [2]
Meladori Magpie [3]
Rotten Apples [5]
Jupiter's Lament [3]
Medellia of the Grey Skies [4]
The Last Song [6]
Transformer [4]
My Blue Heaven [3]