I reckon a team of Butch Vig and Flood would bring them back to their best ... they are both able to draw out the best in any band and they've worked with the pumpkins before. A Gish/MCIS/American Gothic would sound amazing.
Totally agree with the less production thing and maybe if billy did a bit less of everything in the studio and let the band work as a team they could discover a new creative force. I find having to record many tracks yourself ultimately causes over-production...
Anyways if they got Butch n Flood ... i'm drooling thinking of the outcomes
