It's a bit excessive to have three active game threads on the first page of a discussion board.

Exactly

<bump>

Stellar won the Zeitgeist game, amazingly enough. and the best of the rest nominations are now open...somebody wanna update the initial post of this thread?

updated

The 2nd place game is going to be AMAZING!

yes it is, it'll be a tough one too, but in all technicality, it shouldn't win the whole thin because another song that beat it will also be in the finals. But it will be interesting to see if it beats any of the other songs.

It will probably beat some of the songs that never should have won, like Ugly

that was a low shot, haha, ugly's my favorite on tafh

Geek N.Z. wrote:
It will probably beat some of the songs that never should have won, like Ugly

Or Stellar

yea that was a surprise win.

I'm glad "Stellar" won, if "Ma Belle" couldn't have, I'm glad "Stellar" could. However I agree, how in the hell did "Ugly" win???

That is wierd about Ugly winning.
I'm glad Stellar won too, but I don't think it was the best out of the bunch. Ma Belle should have been at the finish.

United States is one of my least favourite songs by SP. It is really tedious until it hits the 6:35 mark. Then it's rockin'.

I like Stellar, it reminds me of the dreamy kind of SP. Ma Belle is kind of a mix of dreamy and rockin'.

There is a reason that stellar and ma belle are B-SIDES!! They didn't even make the album. United States has one of the most epic drum tracks ever recorded, and it was done in one take. That's all I'm saying.

don't get wrong, i love stellar, and i do think ma belle should have been on the actual album, stellar could've too, but i thought other tracks should've beat it. but that's why we have the final survivor in the end.

The reason Stellar and Ma Belle are B-sides are because they didn't fit in the mood/feeling/whatever of the album, not because they weren't good enough. Otherwise I don't think they would bother playing them live (Okay, Ma Belle hasn't been played live, but the others have. And I don't think they would of bothered recording Ma Belle if they didn't like it, otherwise it would of stayed at demo stage or something.)

I'll agree that the drums are great, but come on, the whole song can't rely on that. IMO the rest of the song is bland, and merely an attempt at doing an epic song for the sake of having a long song on the album. I think Stellar, at 6:20-something is long enough to be epic.

The fact that the drums were recorded in one take means that is a really good and talented drummer. It doesn't mean the song is good because of it.

Silverfuck or Geek U.S.A. or Fuck you or Lucky 13 are some damn epic drum songs.

Sorry if I come off as kind of hostile saying all that..

EDIT: Don't forget Superchrist! A bit of a lame song, but I think it's much more Pumpkins sounding than US.